Current:Home > MyThe Supreme Court upholds the conviction of woman who challenged expert testimony in a drug case-InfoLens
The Supreme Court upholds the conviction of woman who challenged expert testimony in a drug case
View Date:2024-12-23 16:42:57
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld the conviction of a California woman who said she did not know about a stash of methamphetamine hidden inside her car.
The 6-3 opinion came in a case that revolved around how much expert witnesses can say about a defendant’s mindset.
Delilah Guadalupe Diaz was sentenced to seven years in prison after on drug charges after Border Patrol agents discovered methamphetamine worth nearly $370,000 stashed inside the car door panel as she crossed the U.S.-Mexico border.
Diaz contended the car belonged to a boyfriend and that she did not know the drugs were inside. Defense lawyers argued that she was a “blind mule,” a term for people used by cartels to smuggle drugs without their knowledge.
Prosecutors disagreed. They called as an expert witness a Homeland Security agent who testified that drug cartels do not usually send large quantities of drugs with people who are unaware of the contraband, though the agent acknowledged that has happened.
Diaz appealed her conviction, arguing the agent’s testimony broke a rule of evidence that expert witnesses cannot give opinions on a defendant’s mental state.
Prosecutors countered that the agent was speaking from his own expertise and that his testimony did not break that rule because it did not make any references to Diaz specifically.
Lower courts had split on that distinction. Judges in some parts of the country have allowed more general expert testimony about mental state while others kept it out, her lawyers argued.
The case is Diaz v. United States, 23-14
___
Follow the AP’s coverage of the U.S. Supreme Court at https://apnews.com/hub/us-supreme-court.
veryGood! (1)
Related
- Fate of Netflix Series America’s Sweethearts: Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders Revealed
- How to watch and stream 'The Prison Confessions of Gypsy Rose Blanchard' Lifetime special
- Civil rights lawsuit filed over 2022 Philadelphia fire that killed 9 children and 3 adults
- Pedro Pascal, Melanie Lynskey, the Obamas among nominees at creative arts Emmy Awards
- Brian Austin Green’s Fiancée Sharna Burgess Celebrates Megan Fox’s Pregnancy News
- Nebraska bill would add asphyxiation by nitrogen gas as form of execution for death row inmates
- Los Angeles County has thousands of ‘unclaimed dead.’ These investigators retrace their lives
- Man who lunged at judge in court reportedly said he wanted to kill her
- How Kim Kardashian Navigates “Uncomfortable” Situations With Her 4 Kids
- As South Carolina population booms, governor wants to fix aging bridges with extra budget money
Ranking
- Why Josh O'Connor Calls Sex Scenes Least Sexy Thing After Challengers With Zendaya and Mike Faist
- Do 'Home Town' stars Erin, Ben Napier think about retiring? Their answer, and design advice
- Do 'Home Town' stars Erin, Ben Napier think about retiring? Their answer, and design advice
- Nude man nabbed by police after ‘cannonball’ plunge into giant aquarium at Bass Pro Shop in Alabama
- Charles Hanover: A Summary of the UK Stock Market in 2023
- Why Eva Longoria Won't Cast Her 5-Year-Old Son Santiago In a Movie
- Turkish justice minister says 15 suspects jailed ahead of trial for spying for Israel
- The Bachelorette's Tyler Cameron Wants You To Reject Restrictive New Year’s Resolutions
Recommendation
-
Jax Taylor Breaks Silence on Brittany Cartwright Dating His Friend Amid Their Divorce
-
Ryan and Trista Sutter's 2 Kids Are All Grown Up in Rare Appearance at Golden Bachelor Wedding
-
A magnitude 4.1 earthquake shakes a wide area of Southern California, no injuries reported
-
Thousands of opposition activists languish in prison as Bangladesh gears up for national election
-
CFP bracket prediction: SEC adds a fifth team to field while a Big Ten unbeaten falls out
-
USA wins gold medal at world junior championship with victory vs. Sweden
-
Brazil postpones visa requirements for U.S., Canada and Australia citizens to April
-
McDonald's CEO says Israel-Hamas war is having a meaningful impact on its business